Friday, August 21, 2009

The Healthcare Debate's Missing Ingredient

Healthcare impacts much more than just national policy and economics.  A major shortcoming of the ongoing debate is that it largely overlooks the whole concept of prevention: a better life and better living by addressing root causes. 


A fundamental pillar of Shamanic healthcare in the Amazon is spirituality, a belief that deep healing happens in the invisible realm, or otherwise happens in the realm of the placebo  that is, between your ears.

Shamans are masters of both of these “alternative” types of healing, and logic dictates that the global conservation agenda should focus more on the need to preserve their specialized knowledge and the plants they employ, directly demonstrating why people in our industrialized and often stressed-out society have a stake in these far-off cultures and forests.  Why should we care about the Amazon?  Why should people concern themselves with the fate of the Shamans?  Whether you’re worried about your own health, that of your children, or that of the planet, it’s all tied together.


The urgent global need for the preservation of forests, the preservation of biodiversity and the preservation of indigenous forms of healing and diagnosis should be merged into the broader healthcare discussion because we have a personal wellness stake in each of these issues.  The Shamans I have come to know see no personal health without the health of their environment—in the face of increasing resource depletion and climate change, I believe this is an understanding to which we are all now being led.

3 comments:

  1. I appreciate your input on the debate Dr. Plotkin...but I must ask, why do you feel this has yet to be a staple in the national debate? Homeopathic medicines, old family "secrets" if you will, seem to hold credence in many cultures except ours. I'd love to hear your input.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm ecstatic to find that someone has finally taken the time to introduce this topic to the ongoing health care debate. Shamans are vital components to the well-being of their respective tribes. But I'm curious to know that if there are, in fact, practical uses for Shaman medicines on the world stage can more serious attention be given to their plight?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Well I guess the real question is...what good will this knowledge do us? How long will it take the FDA to approve these options? I mean, we need more options, more choices sooner rather than later. I agree with personal wellness, but I don't agree with our Congress dicatating what that means for us.

    ReplyDelete